The Magnificent Frigate Bird

VulcanSpirit
Richard & Alison Brunstrom
Sat 28 Apr 2012 00:29
Darwin's genius was to recognise from readily observed phenomena the fact that species of plants and animals, previously held to be immutable, must and do change over time. He realised that the individuals of all species vary, and that this variety can be used by humans or nature to effect lasting change. He had three classes of evidence; all three are still in use scentifically today.
The first was selective breeding, or artificial selection. Blindingly obvious, in retrospect. Man has selectively bred domestic animals and plants for millenia - think dogs (all of which are genetically wolves, although they may have been domesticated more than once), roses, fancy pigeons or maize and wheat. Humans have selectively bred for characteristics they found valuable; in doing so we  unknowingly (before Darwin) exploited the natural genetic variation within each species (remembering that Darwin knew nothing of genetics).
The second is sexual selection. Think for example of peacocks, or pheasants or birds of paradise. In these cases the female bird herself choses a mate based upon some characteristic that she finds attractive. This process (we now know) can start a genetic positive feedback loop resulting in almost absurd developments. The size of the male peacock's tail is limited only by the adverse impact that having it confers on his own survivability. A balance is struck, driven by female (in these cases) preference. It can have quite astonishing results.
A case in point is the Magnificent Frigate Bird Fregata magnificens which nests on Galapagos and was known to Darwin. Here are a couple on the nest on Seymour Norte; the male on the right has metallic green feathers on his back:
 
 
 
These are large birds (wingspan of about 1.5metres) which get much of their food by stealing it from other species of seabird on the wing. They are fantastic acrobats and swoop right down to the surface of the sea - but if they go in the drink they're dead, for strangely for a seabird they cannot take off from water. But notice the red throat of the male. Here he is displaying:
 
 
That red throat is in fact a huge pouch of skin which he can inflate at will. Not only is it a visual signal, he can also use it rather like a frog's vocal sack to magnify his calls. He selects a good perch, inflates his chest, and spreads his wings to show to the females (who cruise past overhead) what a superb specimen he is. If he's lucky, one will choose him. This 'crazy' pouch which has no other utility is as good an example of sexual selection as a peacock's tail and every bit as beautiful. But no-one had ever thought of sexual selection, nor of its consequences, before Darwin.
But his real impact, which was to turn the scientific and religious world upside down, was his theory of natural selection.